
The Complete Interviewing Method
Prepare the person before you test the account.
Teach to Talk is a complete investigative interviewing method built on one idea: before you ask a person for an important account, teach them how the conversation works, and teach the interviewer how to protect what they say. One standard for victims, witnesses, and suspects.
The goal is not more words. It is the best information genuinely available, with its source, certainty, and limits intact.
You don’t need a script. You need a strategy.
Teach to Talk does not assume that cooperation produces competence.
Most people are asked for an account before anyone teaches them the task. Interviewers routinely tell people to start at the beginning, provide every detail, take their time, and avoid guessing. Those instructions sound obvious to the interviewer. They are not necessarily obvious to the person being interviewed.
What counts as a detail? Should an estimate be reported as a fact? Does “everything” include information learned later? Is silence truly permitted? Can the person correct the interviewer? What happens when memory reaches its limit? When the rules remain hidden, people improvise. They rush, omit, summarize, guess, wait for narrow questions, or blend direct experience with inference and later information. Teach to Talk makes the task visible before the account begins.
Hidden Rules
The person is expected to perform an unfamiliar communication task without being shown how.
Lost Ownership
Narrow or premature questioning can replace the person’s organization with the interviewer’s theory.
Blurred Information
Observation, inference, estimate, and later-acquired information can quietly merge into one account.
Teach first. Then ask.
Established methods such as the Cognitive Interview and PEACE already explain the interview to the person. Teach to Talk makes teaching the person the starting point, and checks that they can apply it before the account begins. It teaches both people in the room.
The interviewer learns to prepare lawfully, ask without leading, protect the first account, develop and clarify it, test it fairly against evidence, repair breakdowns, and return the account accurately.
The interviewee learns the task: what useful detail means, how to separate what they experienced from what they worked out or learned later, that estimates are labeled as estimates, that “I don’t know” is an acceptable answer, and that correcting the interviewer is expected.
Both standards are taught, rehearsed on a neutral object (the Pen Standard), and verified through performance before the real account begins. The same standard then runs through every later part of the interview, and through the established, research-supported methods ASC teaches inside it.
Victims, witnesses, and suspects. One standard.
Role changes the safeguards, not the standard. Victims, witnesses, and suspects receive different warnings, protections, and legal treatment. They do not receive different rules for giving an accurate account. For a person telling the truth, the Teach to Talk standard is designed to produce fuller, better-sourced accounts with fewer guesses. For a person who chooses to mislead, it is designed to produce a detailed, committed account full of specific claims that can be checked against evidence. Either way, the investigator leaves with an account worth investigating, and no one is pressured toward a confession.
A Teach to Talk account protects six qualities.
A strong opening gives the interviewer more than agreement that the person understands. The person shows the skills they practiced, and the account that follows keeps them intact.
Ownership
The account comes out in the person’s own words and in their own order.
Detail
The small things that seem unimportant stay in, even when the person has no idea they matter to the case.
Source
What the person saw firsthand remains separate from what they figured out or heard later.
Certainty
Estimates and approximations stay labeled as such.
Correction
The person can change, qualify, or add to an answer without being treated as inconsistent simply for doing so.
Limits
“I don’t know” and “I don’t remember” are accepted when they are genuine.
An account matters more than a confession.
In Joe’s words: “I was taught to chase confessions. I no longer accept that as the measure of a good interviewer.” He judges an interview by the quality of the information obtained, how faithfully it was preserved, and how carefully it was tested, in public- and private-sector investigations alike.
A confession can matter, but it does not end the work: the circumstances of the statement, the origin of its details, and the independent evidence still have to be examined. The same discipline applies to accusations. Victims and witnesses can be mistaken or untruthful, just as suspects can tell the truth. A person’s role does not establish the accuracy of their account.
That is why the person tells their account freely, in their own words, before questions or evidence shape it. If evidence later shows a material claim was false, the finding does not depend on an admission: the record shows what was said, what the evidence establishes, and why the two cannot be reconciled. An interview that exposes a false accusation and clears an innocent person is a successful interview.
Developed by Joe. Named and defined.
Teach to Talk is the method. The Adaptive Strategies Compass™ is its navigation. These are the components Joe developed to carry the standard from the opening to the close.
TEACH
The five-function opening: Tell the frame, Explain the account standard, Apply it neutrally, Create reciprocal control, Hand over after verification.
A tool of the Teach direction
Pen Standard
The opening demonstration. The person describes the interviewer’s pen from across the table, then watches the interviewer break it into its parts. It teaches fine-grained detail, the difference in access between outside observation and owned experience, and the rule “never create a detail.”
A tool of the Teach direction
Pen Contrast
The later return to the pen when an otherwise detailed account suddenly compresses near the incident. The interviewer summarizes the whole answer, says only that they want to make sure they have everything from that last answer, brings the pen back without identifying the precise gap, and offers a fresh route into memory.
A tool of the Retrieve direction
Adaptive Strategies Compass
The navigation tool inside Teach to Talk: eight directions, and four navigation decisions (stay, shift, stack, stop).
When an interview starts to struggle, it tells you which way to turn.
Difference Audit and Fair Challenge Test
ASC’s checks before a discrepancy is put to the person, with evidence introduced through the Disclosure Ladder.
The core ASC tools of the Test direction
Disclosure Ladder
ASC’s three ways of introducing evidence (the Bridge Question, the Basis Statement, and Full Disclosure), informed by Strategic Use of Evidence (Granhag, Hartwig & colleagues). Source-neutral questions come first, and the three are used in a fixed order, though not all three back to back on every discrepancy.
A tool of the Test direction
RETURN Sequence
ASC’s accuracy close: Reorient, Echo, Take corrections, Unresolved, Road ahead, Note.
How the interview closes, including when the Compass decision is Stop
These components are practitioner-developed and research-informed, and grounded in Joe’s 24-year career with the New York State Police. As a complete method, Teach to Talk has not yet been independently validated.
Hand over the floor only after you have seen, not just heard, that they are ready.
TEACH is the opening of the Teach to Talk method. It prepares the person before substantive questioning begins. The rest of the method protects, develops, tests, and returns the account.
Through the five TEACH functions, the interviewer explains the process, demonstrates the communication standard with the pen, and checks that the person can apply it before handing over the narrative floor. Their wording adapts to the person, role, authority, communication needs, and setting. In the Compass, TEACH and the Pen Standard are the tools of the Teach direction, and the interviewer returns to them whenever the task changes.
Tell the Frame
The interviewer explains who they are, why the conversation is occurring, how it will work, who is present, how it will be recorded or documented, how information may be used, and what meaningful rights, choices, and limits apply. Communication and access needs are addressed before performance is evaluated.
Explain the Account Standard
The interviewer teaches that accuracy outranks speed and volume. The person is asked for every genuinely available detail while distinguishing direct experience, inference, estimates, later-acquired information, and genuine limits such as “I don’t know” or “I don’t remember.”
Apply It Neutrally
The interviewer uses the Pen Standard to let the person practice the rules on neutral material before applying them to consequential memory.
Create Reciprocal Control
The interviewer and the person establish pace, silence, clarification, correction, breaks, and shared pause or slow-down signals. Expectations run in both directions.
Hand Over After Verification
The interviewer verifies understanding through performance, resolves remaining barriers, makes a proceed, revisit, adapt, or delay-or-stop decision, and then transfers the narrative floor with a broad invitation.
Reciprocal control runs in both directions. The person learns how to slow, pause, and correct the process; the interviewer watches how the conversation is going and adjusts the process before the account suffers.
The pen teaches the standard, and stays to protect it.
“Early on, before we get to what happened, I hold up a pen so the person can see it, then ask them to describe it using only what they can see from where they are sitting. In my experience, almost everyone adds something they cannot actually see. They tell me it writes in black ink. They name the brand. They say it is six inches long. So I ask a simple question: ‘How do you know?’ They have not seen it write. The brand is a guess based on the shape. None of it is dishonest. It is the ordinary way people talk, filling small gaps without noticing. Everyone does it, and most days it costs nothing. In an interview, it can cost a great deal. So we practice the difference with a pen, where nothing is at stake, before the person ever tells me what is at stake.”
The Pen Standard uses the interviewer’s own pen to demonstrate fine-grained description, information access, source boundaries, uncertainty, and the limits of memory. The person first describes what can be observed from across the table. The interviewer then describes and disassembles a familiar pen, showing how experience can provide access to information unavailable to an outsider.
The interviewer also teaches the limit of the analogy: memory is not a physical object available for complete inspection. Experiencing an event does not guarantee that every detail was perceived, retained, or remains retrievable. The pen stays in view as a familiar reminder of the standard. The interviewer never announces in advance that it will be used if detail drops.
When an otherwise detailed account suddenly compresses near the incident, the interviewer returns to the pen. The interviewer summarizes the whole answer, says only that they want to make sure they have everything from that last answer, brings the pen back without identifying the precise gap, and offers a fresh route into memory. The interviewer never tells the person in advance that the pen may return, and never identifies the exact point where detail dropped. The cue is not a truth test. In the Compass, the Pen Contrast is a tool of the Retrieve direction.
Object-based detail demonstrations exist in investigative-interviewing practice and research. The Teach to Talk application is defined by the complete use of the pen: neutral rehearsal, explicit memory boundaries, performance-based teach-back, and a continuing non-accusatory cue used to restore the shared information standard throughout the interview.
The communication standard continues through the interview.
After the opening, the interviewer protects the first account, returns for detail, clarifies meaning, and examines differences. When evidence supports a challenge, the interviewer puts that evidence beside the person’s account and gives them room to explain. The interview closes with the RETURN Sequence: an accurate record of what was said, what changed, and what remains to be investigated.
The work includes:
- Preparing the person and teaching the communication task.
- Obtaining and protecting the first account.
- Developing detail and supporting recall where appropriate.
- Clarifying meaning and examining differences.
- Comparing the account with evidence and exploring the explanation.
- Closing accurately and identifying further investigative work.
These tasks do not require a rigid sequence. The Compass helps the interviewer decide when to stay with the current direction, shift to another, stack a second direction in support, or stop.
Inside that work, ASC runs established, research-supported methods on the Teach to Talk standard, each credited to its originators: the Cognitive Interview (Fisher & Geiselman), Strategic Use of Evidence (Granhag, Hartwig & colleagues), the PEACE framework (England and Wales), and the ACCESS Model (Shepherd & colleagues). See how they fit together on Methodologies.
Communication problems travel across sectors. Legal and organizational rules do not.
The five TEACH functions remain consistent. The frame must change with the room. Role and setting change the safeguards, not the standard.
Law Enforcement and Public Safety
Status, custody, voluntariness, warnings, counsel, recording, safety, and use of statements must be resolved before the account begins.
Workplace and HR Investigations
Authority, investigator role, participation expectations, confidentiality limits, anti-retaliation protections, representation, and information sharing must be clear.
Education and Title IX
Role, process, support measures, privacy limits, advisor participation, institutional policy, and decision-making separation must be accurately framed.
Attorneys and Legal Interviews
Representation, privilege, work-product boundaries, purpose, recording, preparation versus fact development, and downstream use must be understood.
Insurance, Sports, and Other Regulated Settings
Contractual duties, authorization, recording, confidentiality, reporting, safeguarding, and external referral requirements must be tailored to the applicable system.
Strategy remains human, purposeful, and adaptive.
The operational TEACH sequence sits inside ASC’s larger communication philosophy.
Strategic Empathy
Understand the person’s perspective, perceived risk, motivations, and communication needs well enough to create a workable path to information. Strategic empathy does not require agreement and does not promise a preferred outcome.
Purposeful Dialogue
Every question, instruction, pause, and disclosure should serve a defined purpose. The interviewer knows what communication problem each technique is intended to solve.
Adaptive Practice
The interviewer changes language, pace, sequence, and support in response to the person and the conditions without abandoning lawful requirements or the method’s core functions.
The Adaptive Strategies Compass is the navigation tool inside Teach to Talk. When an interview starts to struggle, it tells you which way to turn. Teach to Talk is the method; the Compass is its navigation. The Teach direction returns to TEACH whenever the person needs clearer instruction or the task changes.
Established science, practitioner architecture, honest boundaries.
Teach to Talk incorporates principles supported by Cognitive Interview research, rapport and procedural-justice research, non-coercive information-gathering practices, the Méndez Principles, and other established interviewing work. ASC credits those sources directly.
Teach to Talk combines practitioner-developed instruction and navigation with established, research-supported interviewing methods, which retain their own attribution and evidence base. Research supporting individual components does not independently validate the complete method. ASC presents Teach to Talk as practitioner-developed and research-informed, not yet independently validated as a complete method; superiority over other well-conducted interviewing approaches has not been established.
Established Research Incorporated
- Cognitive Interview research (Fisher & Geiselman)
- Rapport research
- Procedural justice (Tyler)
- Non-coercive information-gathering practice
- The Méndez Principles
- Object- and model-demonstration research (the Model Statement technique, Leal, Vrij and colleagues, 2015; Demonstration for More Detail, Boon, Milne, Rosloot & Heinsbroek, 2020)
- Interview ground rules and practice (NICHD Protocol; Lamb, Orbach and colleagues)
ASC Practitioner-Developed Architecture
- The five-function TEACH opening sequence
- The complete Pen Standard application
- The Pen Contrast
- Performance-based teach-back and verification
- The continuing non-accusatory reset cue
- The Disclosure Ladder (three ways of introducing evidence in a fixed order; the Bridge Question has the form of the Reid bait question, and the Basis Statement and Full Disclosure draw on Strategic Use of Evidence and the challenge stage of PEACE) and the RETURN Sequence (a way of carrying out the Closure stage of PEACE)
- Cross-sector framing of the same architecture
Training is measured by performance, not attendance.
Participants practice how to:
- Frame public- and private-sector interviews accurately.
- Identify access and communication barriers before evaluating an account.
- Teach source, certainty, correction, and limits in ordinary language.
- Deliver the complete Pen Standard without creating pressure for detail.
- Establish reciprocal pace, pause, clarification, and correction controls.
- Verify readiness through performance rather than “Do you understand?”
- Transfer the narrative floor and protect the first account.
- Use the pen later as a neutral reset cue, and the Pen Contrast when detail drops near the incident.
- Repair an interviewer-caused interruption without accusing the person.
- Distinguish the guided introduction, retrieval support, and use of evidence within the complete interviewing method.
Developed in 2016. Taught for operational use.
Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr. developed and named Teach to Talk in 2016 while serving with the New York State Police, and taught it at the New York State Police Academy from 2016 through 2023. The original method drew on PEACE, the ACCESS Model, and the Cognitive Interview; later iterations incorporated Strategic Use of Evidence. Its pen demonstration was in use four years before the Demonstration for More Detail study (Boon, Milne, Rosloot & Heinsbroek) was published in 2020, and it was not derived from that study. The chronology documents authorship; it does not claim priority over earlier interview instructions or object demonstrations. Teach to Talk® is a registered service mark of Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr.
Teach to Talk reflects Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr.’s 24 years of investigative experience and ASC’s work with professionals across law enforcement, government, education, legal, workplace, and other high-stakes settings. Testimonials describe participant experience with ASC instruction; they are not substitutes for independent outcome validation.
What Professionals Are Saying
“Joe, you were a great instructor. We learned a lot from you and will take on some of what we learned. Would highly recommend you to anyone interested.”
Deputy Chief of Investigations Salvatore Salerno, NY State Justice CenterThe interview begins before the first substantive question.
Teach the process. Rehearse the standard. Verify readiness. Then hand over the account.
Common questions about Teach to Talk.
Is Teach to Talk a script?
No. Teach to Talk is a complete interviewing method, not a script. Its opening, TEACH, has five functions, and the Adaptive Strategies Compass, its navigation framework, helps the interviewer decide which way to turn as the conversation develops. The wording and choice of approach respond to the person, task, and circumstances.
Is Teach to Talk the same as Cognitive Interviewing?
No. The Cognitive Interview, developed by Ronald Fisher, R. Edward Geiselman, and colleagues, is one of the most extensively researched interviewing methods. Teach to Talk is the complete method described here. ASC runs the Cognitive Interview on the Teach to Talk standard as a credited tool in the Retrieve direction, so new recall arrives with its source and certainty intact.
Does the Pen Standard prove that someone should remember details?
No. The pen demonstrates information access and fine-grained description. It also teaches that memory has limits. Experiencing an event does not guarantee that every detail was encoded, retained, or remains retrievable.
What does the pen mean later in the interview?
It is a shared cue to slow down, return to the moment, break it into smaller pieces, search for genuine detail, preserve source and uncertainty, and stop where memory stops. It is not an accusation and does not require the person to produce more. When a detailed account suddenly compresses near the incident, the interviewer may use the Pen Contrast: summarize the whole answer, say only that you want to make sure you have everything from that last answer, bring the pen back without identifying the precise gap, and offer a fresh route into memory.
Can Teach to Talk be used with suspects and respondents?
Yes. Role changes the safeguards, not the standard. Victims, witnesses, and suspects receive different warnings, protections, and legal treatment, but the same rules for giving an accurate account. Teach to Talk is adapted to the person’s legal and organizational status and never replaces required warnings, rights, representation, consent, or policy protections.
Can it be used in workplace investigations?
Yes. The same communication architecture applies, but the interviewer must accurately explain authorization, role, participation expectations, confidentiality limits, anti-retaliation protections, representation, and information use.
Is Teach to Talk evidence-based?
Teach to Talk is practitioner-developed and research-informed, grounded in Joe’s 24-year career with the New York State Police. Its components draw on established interviewing and behavioral-science research, and the research engines it runs (the Cognitive Interview, Strategic Use of Evidence, PEACE, and ACCESS) are research-supported and credited to their originators. Teach to Talk has not yet been independently validated as a complete method.
Does Teach to Talk determine whether someone is truthful?
No. Teach to Talk does not determine honesty from behavior, detail, or compliance with instructions. It helps the interviewer obtain, clarify, preserve, and test an account. Observation manages the conversation. Evidence tests the account. Claims must be examined against evidence, including evidence that supports the person’s account or clears them.