Home/Training/True Insight
Evaluators with clipboards watching an athlete sprint past a timing clock during an indoor speed test
College & Pro Sports Training
Recruit & Transfer Evaluation · Character Assessment · Internal Investigations

The rehearsed answer is not the real answer.

True Insight is the ASC course for Division I athletic departments and professional front offices: recruit, transfer, and prospect evaluation, character assessment, and internal conduct interviews that get past media training to an authentic read, without pushing the athlete into better rehearsal.

Communication Adaptation·Observation for Rapport·Authentic Assessment·Defensible Internal Findings

Built by a former Senior Investigator with the New York State Police and lead instructor at the NYS Police Academy for Investigative Interviewing.

Sector
College & Pro Sports
Duration
Half or Full Day
Tuition
From $2,500 / session
Level
Athletics Staff / Front Office
Format
On-Site or Virtual
Credit
Certificate of Completion
Request Training
The Core Principle
Why Evaluations Fail

Most evaluation decisions are made on rehearsed answers, not on the person.

College athletes are now paid. Division I schools that opt in can pay athletes directly under the House v. NCAA settlement, on top of NIL deals. A roster spot is now a financial commitment, and between high school recruiting and the transfer portal, a program makes many of those commitments every year, often after one visit and a few conversations.

By the time a recruit, a transfer, or a draft prospect sits across the table from your staff, they have often been coached: by an agent or NIL representative, a media trainer, or a previous program. The seven failure modes below contaminate the evaluation before it begins.

Q-and-A formats prospects have already practiced
Surface-level questions, surface-level answers
Behavioral mythology mistaken for evidence
Single-cue judgments without a communication reference point
Missing signs that trauma or stress is affecting the account
Prepared answers accepted as the whole story
Evaluation notes too generic to inform a borderline call

True Insight teaches recruiting staff, athletic administrators, and front offices how to move past those failures through a structured, research-informed framework rooted in investigative interviewing science, communication reference-point observation, communication adaptation, and Strategic Use of Evidence (Granhag, Hartwig & colleagues). The communication reference point is how a person ordinarily communicates in this interview. It is used to manage the conversation (rapport, topic difficulty, emotion), never to decide whether a prospect is lying.

The objective is not to catch a prospect lying. The objective is an evaluation that reflects who the prospect actually is, not who their agent prepared them to appear to be.

Built For

Designed for every role that evaluates or investigates inside an athletic department or front office.

True Insight is built for the full range of professionals whose decisions depend on accurate, checkable information about people: recruits and transfers who have been heavily coached, athletes in moments of conflict, and staff and athletes who may be subjects of an internal investigation.

Athletic Directors & Senior Administrators

The administrators accountable for how the department spends revenue-sharing, NIL, and scholarship dollars, and for how it handles conduct matters. The course gives the department one method for both sides of the work: evaluating the athletes it commits to, and interviewing fairly when something goes wrong.

General Managers & Personnel Directors

The staff who now build college rosters the way professional front offices do: transfer-portal targets, high school recruits, and retention conversations. The course delivers a structured interview that surfaces checkable detail before the offer is made, particularly on the borderline calls.

Recruiting Coordinators & Coaching Staff

The coaches and recruiting staff who run official visits, portal calls, and home visits. The course teaches open, structured questioning that moves past the prepared answer to specific accounts of how an athlete has handled pressure, setbacks, and teammates.

Character Coaches & Player Development Staff

The staff responsible for evaluating intangibles, locker-room fit, leadership profile, and high-pressure response. The course adds investigative-grade discipline to character work, with the structured questioning and communication-adaptation discipline that separates a character read grounded in verified detail from a gut feel.

Compliance Officers & Conduct Investigators

The staff handling athlete conduct matters, team-rule violations, and internal reviews. The course adapts every technique for the procedural requirements these interviews demand: impartiality, documentation, and findings built to withstand review by a conference, the NCAA, a league office, or a court.

Professional Front Offices & Scouting

General managers, scouting directors, player personnel, and team-security staff running pre-draft visits, free-agent evaluations, and background interviews. ASC first delivered this training inside Major League Baseball, with the Texas Rangers’ amateur scouting staff.

Course Overview

What you'll learn and apply

Delivered as a half-day or full-day session, on site or virtual, True Insight teaches college athletics staff and professional front offices how to conduct interviews that get beyond rehearsed answers and surface genuine character and specific, checkable detail about past conduct and decisions. Drawing on the same research-informed methods used in law enforcement and HR, True Insight gives athletic departments and sports organizations a more disciplined evaluation process.

Learning Outcomes

  • Recruiting and scouting interview frameworks that go beyond surface-level answers
  • Noticing when an answer is generic or prepared, and using open questions to get specific, checkable detail
  • Communication adaptation and observation for rapport, topic difficulty, emotion, and style
  • Gathering verified, specific information so evaluation decisions rest on facts, not impressions
  • Surfacing checkable detail about past incidents before a roster or contract commitment
  • Applying these skills to fair internal misconduct investigations
  • Keeping questions within the rules: NCAA, conference, state, and school rules on contact with recruits and student-athletes, with juvenile safeguards first for recruits under 18, and for professional clubs, ADA limits on disability-related questions before a conditional job offer and the league and collective-bargaining rules that govern questioning of players and prospects
The Framework, Calibrated for Sports Organizations

The Compass, calibrated for sports organizations. Prospect evaluation and internal investigations.

Eight directions, no fixed order. Move to whichever one the conversation needs, as often as it needs it.

The methodology this course delivers is organized around the Adaptive Strategies Compass™, the navigation tool inside Teach to Talk®: when an interview starts to struggle, it tells you which way to turn. Each direction maps to a moment where front offices and athletic departments lose accuracy, authenticity, or defensibility.

Direction

Teach

Do they know how to do this?

Setting expectations so a prospect knows you want genuine detail, not the media-trained answer.

Direction

Listen

Is this still their account?

Letting the prospect tell their own story before your evaluation questions shape it.

Direction

Retrieve

Is there more they genuinely remember?

Getting fuller, more accurate accounts of past incidents and decisions than direct questioning produces.

Direction

Clarify

Do I understand what they mean, and how they know it?

Turning rehearsed generalities into specific, checkable detail.

Direction

Adapt

Is how I’m communicating working for this person?

Reading each prospect's pace and focus and adjusting so they open up. A rapport tool, never a prediction of fit or performance.

Direction

Re-engage

Can they answer, but won’t?

A rehearsed prospect isn't a dishonest one. When image, teammates, or family are being protected, addressing that instead of pushing.

Direction

Test

Does the account hold up against the evidence?

Checking the account against what your staff has already verified, without revealing it too early.

Direction

Route

Where is this conversation going?

Planning prospect interviews and internal investigations from first contact to decision.

Athletic departments and front offices leave with the complete Compass, calibrated for the interviews and investigations they actually conduct.

In Their Words

"Many of us have continued to draw from your lessons in our day to day work."

Our scouts expressed surprise in just how much overlap there was between the role of a NYS Investigator and a baseball scout, specifically interviewing and information gathering. Our group was so moved by your discussion and techniques that many of us have continued to draw from your lessons in our day to day work.

Adam Lewkowicz · Assistant Director, Amateur Scouting · Texas Rangers Baseball Club · January 2020

About the Instructor

Investigative-grade interviewing, applied to the evaluations and investigations that shape a program.

Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr. headshot

Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr.

Certified Forensic Interviewer (CFI) · IADLEST National Certified Instructor (INCI) · Certified Polygraph Examiner · Former Senior Investigator, New York State Police

Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr. is a retired Senior Investigator with the New York State Police, lead instructor at the New York State Police Academy for Investigative Interviewing, and a contributor at the New York State Preparedness Training Center in Investigative Interviewing. Over a 24-year law enforcement career, he conducted or supervised more than 12,000 interviews across high-stakes investigative settings, building the same interview discipline and interview depth (observation for rapport and communication, never lie detection) that separates a quality character evaluation from a check-the-box recruiting visit.

Joe spent thirteen years, from 2010 until he retired in 2023, as an instructor at the New York State Police Academy, teaching investigators to read a person's communication reference point and use open questions to move past prepared answers to specific, checkable information, including from people who do not want to give it. Today he applies that methodology to college and professional sports, helping athletic directors, recruiting and personnel staff, front offices, character coaches, and compliance staff conduct interviews that produce accurate evaluations of who a prospect actually is, and defensible findings when an internal matter requires investigation.

Full Bio →

Closing Note

The interview is the cheapest part of the evaluation. It is also the part that decides whether the rest of it matters.

Transfer-portal commitments fail. Recruiting classes miss. Draft picks fail. Some fail for reasons the tape could not show: a character pattern, an off-field incident, or a pattern of conduct that everyone saw later and nobody surfaced in the conversation. The programs that get evaluation right are not the ones with sharper instincts. They are the ones who interview with structure, behavioral discipline, and the same investigative rigor every other high-stakes interview demands.

Contact ASC to bring True Insight to your athletic department or front office and equip your staff for the conversations that decide whether the evaluation, and the commitment, was worth it.

FAQ

Common questions about this course

How long is the True Insight course and what’s the format?

True Insight is delivered as a half-day (4-hour) or full-day (8-hour) session, on site at your organization or training facility, or virtually. It is designed for athletic department staff and front-office personnel and combines classroom instruction in communication adaptation and observation for rapport and pacing with applied scenarios drawn from recruiting visits, transfer-portal evaluations, pre-draft interviews, and character evaluation contexts.

Who is True Insight designed for?

The course is built first for Division I athletic departments: athletic directors, general managers and personnel directors, recruiting coordinators, coaching staff, character coaches, and compliance staff. It serves professional front offices the same way: scouts, scouting directors, player personnel staff, and general managers who interview prospects.

Why does this matter more now that college athletes are paid?

Because each roster decision now carries more money. Division I schools that opt in can pay athletes directly under the House v. NCAA settlement, in addition to NIL. With the transfer portal, a program may add many athletes each year, often after one visit and a few conversations. The interview is the cheapest part of that decision, and it is where a program can learn what film and statistics cannot show. True Insight teaches staff to get specific, checkable detail in those conversations, inside the NCAA, conference, and school rules that govern them.

What does the True Insight course cover?

Recruiting and scouting interview frameworks that go beyond surface-level answers, noticing when an answer is generic or prepared and using open questions to get specific detail, communication adaptation and observation for rapport, topic difficulty, emotion, and style, gathering specific, checkable accounts of past incidents and decisions so evaluation decisions rest on verified information, and applying these skills to fair internal misconduct investigations.

What are schools and clubs allowed to ask?

The course teaches interviewing inside the rules your organization already operates under, and it flags where they apply. In college athletics, NCAA, conference, state, and school rules govern contact with recruits and student-athletes, and with recruits under 18, juvenile safeguards come first. In professional sports, under the Americans with Disabilities Act, an employer may not ask a job applicant disability-related questions or require a medical exam before making a conditional job offer, though it may ask whether the applicant can perform the job’s functions. League rules and the players’ collective bargaining agreement govern what clubs may ask and collect, including medical and drug-testing information. ASC teaches interviewing, not NCAA, employment, or league law: your compliance office, counsel, and league office set the rules for your interviews.

How does this differ from typical recruiting and scouting interviews?

Most recruiting and scouting interviews follow a Q-and-A format that athletes have rehearsed with agents, advisors, and media trainers. True Insight teaches structured behavioral interviewing, the same research-informed methods used in investigative work, to get past rehearsed responses to specific, checkable detail about the experiences, decisions, and character that don’t appear on tape. Staff walk away with frameworks they can apply in the next visit or interview window.

What is Communication Adaptation and how does it apply to recruiting and scouting interviews?

Communication Adaptation is a process for adjusting the interview to how a prospect is communicating: observe pace, language, and response space, consider what may be affecting the exchange, make the smallest reasonable adjustment, and verify whether it improves the conversation. It helps a coach or scout run a clearer, fairer interview and surface authentic answers. It is not used to type a prospect or predict future performance. It does use a style read from each prospect's pace and focus as a working guess about how much structure and warmth to bring, tested by whether the adjustment helps.

Can the course also be used for internal misconduct investigations?

Yes. The same interviewing skill set applies directly to internal investigations, player conduct issues, staff matters, compliance reviews, and workplace complaints inside the organization. The course explicitly covers fair, defensible investigative interviewing so your department or front office has the same toolkit for evaluating prospects and handling sensitive internal matters.

Can the course be customized for our sport or organization?

Yes. Joe tailors examples and scenarios to your sport and level: Division I, professional, or development league. Scenario work can be weighted toward official visits, transfer-portal evaluation, draft prep, free-agent evaluation, or internal investigations depending on where your staff needs the most lift.

What does the True Insight course cost?

True Insight is priced as a flat rate per session, not per attendee. On site: $3,000 for a half day and $5,000 for a full day, plus travel at actual cost. Virtual: $2,500 for a half day and $4,500 for a full day. Each session serves up to 20 attendees from your organization. Contact ASC to schedule. Joe responds personally and tailors each session to the evaluation decisions your organization is preparing for.

How do I bring True Insight to my organization?

True Insight is delivered on site or virtually for athletic departments, sports organizations, scouting departments, and front offices. Contact ASC through the Request Training form or by calling (914) 489-2330 to discuss scheduling, attendee count, and emphasis areas. Joe responds personally and tailors the curriculum to the evaluation decisions your team is preparing for.

Where True Insight fits in the ASC curriculum

Investigation and evaluation discipline calibrated across sectors that share the same procedural demands.

True Insight is the sports-organization deployment of the broader ASC investigative interviewing curriculum. For internal-investigation work (player conduct, staff matters, harassment complaints) that goes beyond what one day can cover, Strategic Workplace Interviewing delivers the two-day workplace-investigation methodology. For school athletic departments handling Title IX matters, From Complaint to Finding covers the Title IX investigation interview.

Strategic Workplace Interviewing From Complaint to Finding
Planning Details

What to expect, start to finish

Format
A half-day (4-hour) or full-day (8-hour) session, on site or virtual, closed to your organization’s staff.
Group size
Up to 20 attendees per session, on site or virtual.
Included
Attendee workbooks and reference cards, certificate of completion, in-class Q&A, and 30 days of post-course email support from Joe.
Credit
No formal continuing-education credit applicable. Every attendee receives a certificate of completion, and the curriculum is customizable for athletic administration, coaching and recruiting staff, front-office, scouting, and security-and-investigations audiences.
Travel
Billed at actual cost for on-site sessions. No travel charge for virtual sessions.
Booking & policy
Joe scopes every engagement personally and replies within two business days. See the full pricing and formats or the refund & cancellation policy.
For Your Decision File

Get the full syllabus and a sample agenda

Request the complete module-by-module syllabus and a sample agenda for this course, sent to you personally by Joe. It is the document to forward to your athletic director, general manager, or budget approver, the thing that turns "this looks good" into an approved request.

Joe sends it personally, usually the same business day. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy policy.

Ready to bring this course to your team?

Request information or schedule a strategy call to discuss your organization's needs.

Free Field Resource

The Scouting Interview Framework: Beyond the Combine. Free.

Pre-draft character assessment for front offices and player personnel staff. How to get past the rehearsed answer, read the conversation against a communication reference point, and avoid the body-language myths that mislead evaluations. Excerpted from the True Insight course.

  • Getting past the media-trained, rehearsed answer
  • Reading the conversation against a communication reference point
  • Character and pressure-response assessment
  • Avoiding the body-language myths that mislead evaluations

We never sell or rent your information. Our privacy policy lists the service providers we use.

Browse all free resources →