Home/About/Adaptive Strategies Compass
Brass Adaptive Strategies Compass on a walnut desk surrounded by maps, notebooks, and investigative materials under warm directional light
The ASC Navigation Framework

Adaptive Strategies Compass™

When the interview struggles, know which way to turn.

Every interviewer eventually hits the moment when the conversation stalls: answers shrink, rapport slips, a topic goes quiet, or the account collides with the evidence. The usual instinct is to push harder. The Adaptive Strategies Compass asks why first. Eight directions, no fixed order, one for each reason an interview struggles, point the interviewer to the move that fits. It is one framework for victims, witnesses, and suspects, because it reads the condition, not the role.

You don't need a script. You need a strategy.

The navigation tool inside Teach to Talk®·Practitioner-developed·Research-informed

Navigation Inside
Teach to Talk
Developed By
Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr.
Deployed In
Every ASC Course
Browse the Training Catalog
8
Directions, no fixed order, one for each reason an interview struggles
1
Framework for victims, witnesses, and suspects
4
Decisions: stay, shift, stack, stop
24
Years of investigative work behind it

By Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr. · Founder, Advanced Strategic Communications · 24 years, New York State Police

More than a model. A navigation framework.

A compass does not hand you a script for the journey; it gives you direction. The Adaptive Strategies Compass is the navigation tool inside Teach to Talk. When an interview starts to struggle, it tells you which way to turn.

Teach to Talk sets one standard for every person in the chair. The Compass keeps that standard working when the conversation gets hard. It does not tell interviewers what to say. It helps them work out why the interview is struggling, and points to the direction that fits: eight directions, each named for the task it performs.

Established research methods sit inside those directions as credited tools: the Cognitive Interview (Fisher & Geiselman), Strategic Use of Evidence (Granhag, Hartwig & colleagues), the PEACE framework (England and Wales), and the ACCESS Model (Shepherd & colleagues). Placing a method inside the Compass does not make it ASC's.

Scripts are for actors. Interviewers need tools that work when the conversation becomes unpredictable.

Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr. built the Adaptive Strategies Compass in 2023, years after Teach to Talk, as he refined his course and studied the research. It draws on his 24-year career with the New York State Police, on cognitive psychology and forensic interviewing research, and on lessons from real cases including the 2012 People v. Nunez interview and the Brandyn Foster investigation. It is the navigation framework underneath every ASC course.

The Adaptive Strategies Compass with the ASC owl mark at its center
When the Interview Struggles

Pressure is the usual answer. The Compass asks why.

Interviews stall for different reasons. A person may not understand what you're asking. You may have taken over their account without noticing. They may have reached the honest limit of their memory, or used a word you misread. Your pace or style may not fit them. They may be able to answer but afraid, ashamed, protecting someone, or distrustful of the process. Or their account may genuinely conflict with the evidence.

Each of those problems has a different fix, and pressure fixes none of them. Calling a person “resistant” names a feeling, not a cause. The Compass replaces that label with a short, honest check that points to the direction that fits the actual problem.

Resistance is a conclusion. The Compass asks what's causing it.

One Framework for Every Role

Navigate the condition, not the role.

Victims, witnesses, and suspects are different roles with different rights, warnings, and safeguards. They are not different kinds of memory or communication. A frightened victim and a guarded suspect can both go quiet at the critical moment, for different reasons. The Compass asks why before it picks a direction, and the role determines the safeguards that travel with it.

That is why one framework works for everyone. The Teach to Talk standard is the same for every person in the chair: report what you genuinely know, label what you estimate or learned later, don't guess, and correct me when I'm wrong. The Compass helps the interviewer keep that standard working when the conversation gets hard.

Role changes the safeguards, not the standard.

The Signature Tool

Which way? Eight questions, in priority order.

Before the eight questions, one check comes first: has the person invoked a right, or has their legal status, safety, or capacity changed? If so, stop and meet that requirement first. Otherwise, run the eight questions in priority order during a natural pause, without stopping the interview to work through a list. The first one that fits usually points you to the direction to turn. If several fit, the earliest leads and the others can support it.

Teach Listen Retrieve Clarify Adapt Re-engage Test Route
Which way? Eight directions, clockwise from north

The questions are ordered. The directions are not.

  1. Is the person unsure of the task: what I'm asking for, or how to answer it?If yes, turn toTeach
  2. Have I taken over their account by narrowing, interrupting, leading, or supplying details?If yes, turn toListen
  3. Have they reached a memory limit, or could another route help them remember?If yes, turn toRetrieve
  4. Am I unsure what they mean, how they know it, or whether two statements really conflict?If yes, turn toClarify
  5. Is it how I'm communicating: pace, style, rapport, a hard topic, or emotion crowding the account?If yes, turn toAdapt
  6. Can they answer, but won't?If yes, turn toRe-engage
  7. Does a settled, understood account conflict with the evidence?If yes, turn toTest
  8. Have I lost my direction, or did the conversation take a turn I didn't plan for?If yes, turn toRoute

Why this order matters.

The first five questions check the problems the interviewer can fix: the task, the interviewer's own behavior, memory, meaning, and communication. Only after those have been checked, and addressed where possible, does the interviewer consider that the person may be unwilling (6), and only an account that is understood is tested against the evidence (7). Question 8 is the interviewer's own orientation, available at any moment. The order keeps the Compass fair for every role, because the interviewer checks their own contribution before concluding anything about the person.

Check yourself before you conclude they're unwilling.

If more than one fits,

the earliest question leads. For example, if the person is both confused and reluctant, Teach first. Reluctance often eases once the task is clear.

The order sets priorities for checking. It is not a set of gates the conversation must pass through one at a time.

Then decide: stay, shift, stack, or stop →

The Compass Is Fluid

Move in any direction. Return as often as you need.

The eight directions are not steps. An interview often begins with Teach and moves through Listen, Retrieve, and Clarify, but it rarely stays on a straight line. A person who was following the standard starts guessing, so you turn back to Teach. Once the rule lands, you return to Retrieve. Then the topic gets hard and rapport starts to slip, so you turn to Adapt. Within a few minutes you may cross the Compass three times.

You can move from any direction to any other, and come back to a direction as often as the conversation needs. What keeps that movement disciplined is the “Which way?” check. The questions are ordered, because that order makes you check yourself before you conclude the person is unwilling. The directions are not ordered, because conversations aren't.

  1. Teach
  2. Listen
  3. Retrieve
  4. Clarify
  5. Teach
  6. Retrieve
  7. Adapt
One real path through an interview. Yours will be different every time.
The Eight Directions

Eight directions, no fixed order. One for each reason an interview struggles.

Each direction is named for a task and defined by the moment you turn to it. Established research methods are credited tools inside the directions, not directions of their own. Select a direction to read its full write-up.

Teach

Do they know how to do this?

Cue

“Teach first. Then ask.”

Turn here when…

the person is guessing, sounds certain about things they couldn't know, blends what they saw with what they heard later, rushes, or waits for narrow questions. Always at the start of an interview, and again whenever the task changes: a new topic, a sketch, a break, or a change in the person's status.

What you do

  • Explain the task in plain words: what useful detail means, and that “I don't know” is acceptable.
  • Demonstrate the standard with the Pen Standard.
  • Let the person practice on neutral material before the real account.
  • Check by performance, not by asking “Do you understand?”
  • Teach again only the rule that didn't land, then check again.

Tools

ASCTEACH (Tell, Explain, Apply, Create, Hand over) · the Pen Standard · reciprocal controls and shared signals · the readiness decision (proceed, revisit, adapt, or delay or stop).

CreditedCognitive Interview instructions to report everything and not guess (Fisher & Geiselman) · interview ground-rule practice research (NICHD Protocol; Lamb, Orbach and colleagues) · research on demonstrating expected detail (Model Statement, Leal, Vrij and colleagues; Demonstration for More Detail, Boon, Milne and colleagues).

Across roles

The same standard for everyone. What changes is the frame: the warnings, rights, representation, and confidentiality limits that apply to the person's role and your authority.

What it is not

A speech, a rapport trick, or a substitute for legally required warnings.

Listen

Is this still their account?

Cue

“Whose account is this?”

Turn here when…

you are talking more than they are; you asked several questions at once, interrupted, or led; your summary added something they never said; answers have shrunk to yes or no; or you supplied a detail before they did.

What you do

  • Stop questioning. Give the floor back with one open invitation built from their own words (“Tell me…,” “Describe…,” “Walk me through…”).
  • Protect the answer: no interruptions, and let the pause sit after they stop.
  • Take brief jot notes of the people, locations, actions, times, and objects they mention, in their order.
  • Summarize for correction: “What have I missed or misunderstood?”
  • If you supplied something, repair it out loud: “I assumed something in that question you hadn't told me. Let me ask it differently.”

Tools

ASCOne-question-at-a-time discipline · summary for correction · open repair. Protecting the first account is established practice drawn from PEACE, the Cognitive Interview, and Strategic Use of Evidence; ASC teaches it and does not claim it.

CreditedTEDS-PIE question framing (Tell, Explain, Describe, Show; Precisely, In detail, Exactly) and PLATO jot notes (People, Locations, Actions, Time, Objects), established training mnemonics ASC did not create · College of Policing guidance on free narrative and non-leading questioning.

Across roles

Every first account belongs to the person who gives it, including a suspect's account that will later be tested. Protecting it is what makes later testing fair. If the account later changes, each version is recorded with what came immediately before it and the person's own explanation, so testimony can describe how the account developed without guessing why (documenting a changing account).

What it is not

Passive silence. You still choose the subject, manage safeguards, and decide what comes next.

Retrieve

Is there more they genuinely remember?

Cue

“Another route, never a guess.”

Turn here when…

the account is thin; a detailed account suddenly compresses near the incident (“That's about it”); or the person is trying to remember but stuck.

What you do

  • First check and address your own contribution: an unclear question, an interruption, fatigue, or the setting.
  • Check what the person has discussed, read, or reviewed since the event.
  • If a detailed account compressed near the incident, use the Pen Contrast: summarize the whole answer, say only that you want to make sure you have everything from that last answer, and bring the pen back as a reminder of the standard without identifying the precise gap.
  • Offer one fresh route into memory: context reinstatement, a sketch, category recall, a different starting point, reverse order, or a change of perspective limited to a position they actually occupied.
  • Accept “That's everything I remember” as a complete answer.

Tools

ASCThe Pen Contrast · the source and exposure check · the decision to stop a retrieval attempt.

CreditedThe Cognitive Interview and Enhanced Cognitive Interview (Ronald Fisher, R. Edward Geiselman and colleagues), one of the most extensively researched methods for helping cooperative people recall more correct detail.

Across roles

Central for victims and witnesses. With suspects, it builds the fullest account before anything is tested. Trauma-exposed people may give fragmented or inconsistent accounts; inconsistency is not by itself a sign of dishonesty. Slow the pace and follow trauma-informed safeguards.

What it is not

A lie test. Difficulty remembering, or difficulty working backward, says nothing about honesty. New detail is not corroboration.

Clarify

Do I understand what they mean, and how they know it?

Cue

“Understand it before you test it.”

Turn here when…

a word is vague or loaded (“handled it,” “aggressive,” “approved”); a time sounds precise but may be an estimate; two statements seem to conflict; you can't tell whether a detail was seen, worked out, or learned later; or the person just corrected your summary.

What you do

  • Ask what the word means to them: “When you say 'handled it,' what did you do?”
  • Ask how they know: “What is that based on?”
  • Find out what an estimate rests on, and keep it labeled as an estimate.
  • Before calling anything a contradiction, sort the difference: an addition, an omission, a change, or a genuine conflict. Check that both statements describe the same moment.
  • Keep both the original words and the clarification in the record.

Tools

ASCThe four sources of an account (I experienced it · I worked it out · I learned it later · I can’t place it) · source and certainty checks.

ASC’s organization of established practiceClarification and account reconciliation (sorting a difference as an addition, omission, change, or conflict before anything is tested).

CreditedSource-monitoring research (Johnson, Hashtroudi & Lindsay) · the account-and-clarification stage of the PEACE framework (England and Wales).

Across roles

The same discipline for everyone. With victims, explain why you're asking, so clarification doesn't sound like disbelief.

What it is not

A challenge. Test only an account you understand. If meaning, source, or certainty is still unclear, Clarify first.

Adapt

Is how I'm communicating working for this person?

Cue

“Change me before I change the question.”

Turn here when…

rapport is slipping; a topic is becoming hard to discuss; emotion is crowding out the account; your style doesn't fit theirs (they want brevity and you're explaining; they need time and you're moving fast); or language, an interpreter, disability, or fatigue is affecting the exchange.

What you do: Observe, Consider, Adjust, Verify

  • Observe verbal and nonverbal behavior against the person's communication reference point: how they ordinarily communicate in this interview.
  • Consider more than one explanation, including something you are doing.
  • Adjust with the smallest change that might help: pace, wording, structure, a break, or your style. Use a style read, from the person’s pace and focus, as a working guess about how much structure and warmth to bring.
  • Verify whether it helped. Keep the change if it did; drop it if it didn't.

Tools

ASCCommunication Adaptation (Observe, Consider, Adjust, Verify) · the communication reference point · five rapport behaviors: voice, respect, and neutrality from Tyler’s procedural-justice model, plus predictability and accuracy and accountability, Joe’s additions drawn from the Teach to Talk communication standard.

CreditedORBIT rapport research (Alison and colleagues), including the control and affiliation dimensions of Leary’s interpersonal circle · procedural-justice research (Tom Tyler; Gerald Leventhal) · research on nonverbal markers of rapport (Tickle-Degnen & Rosenthal).

Across roles

Everyone. Trauma-informed adjustments for victims; plain, predictable process for witnesses who fear involvement; for suspects, rapport means a fair working relationship, not agreement.

What it is not

Deception detection or a diagnosis of personality. Observation manages the conversation. Evidence tests the account. And rapport is not niceness: it means predictability and procedural fairness, treating the person the same way whether an answer helps or hurts the case. It does not end when the questions get difficult; a fair challenge relies on it (Rapport and challenge).

Re-engage

Can they answer, but won't?

Cue

“Find the reason, not the pressure.”

Turn here when…

you have checked the task, your own behavior, memory, meaning, and communication, and the person is able to answer but reluctant: hedging, protecting someone, testing your motives, pushing back against pressure, or worried about consequences.

What you do

  • Describe what changed, without assigning a motive: “You were answering in detail; since I asked about the second phone, you've gone quiet.”
  • Pause. Then ask an open check: “What's making this hard to answer?”
  • Explore the barrier with the person. Five recur often enough to name: Fear, Shame, Loyalty, Distrust, and Reactance. They are hypotheses to check, not an exhaustive list.
  • Respond honestly within your authority. Explain the process, the real limits, and what you can and can't promise.
  • Invite a specific return to the task.
  • If conduct (not disagreement) disrupts the interview, use the two-chance boundary.
  • Respect a decision not to answer, and stop when no fair, productive task remains.

Tools

ASCBarrier Mapping (Fear, Shame, Loyalty, Distrust, Reactance) · the barrier assessment · the six-step repair (Notice, Pause, Check, Adjust, Invite, Decide) · the two-chance boundary.

CreditedProcedural justice (Tyler) · psychological reactance theory (Brehm) · Self-Determination Theory (Deci & Ryan) · Motivational Interviewing (Miller & Rollnick) · disclosure-barrier research · the boundary script is adapted from DESC (Bower & Bower).

Across roles

Victims often face fear and shame; witnesses, loyalty and fear of retaliation; suspects and respondents, distrust and reactance. The barrier is explored with the person, never assigned from demeanor.

What it is not

Pressure, minimization, or supplying an excuse. ASC never trades a promised outcome for information.

Test

Does the account hold up against the evidence?

Cue

“Test the material, not the person.”

Turn here when…

the account has been given, developed, and clarified, and a material piece of evidence appears to conflict with it, or an earlier answer may have been misleading.

What you do: audit, check, then challenge.

Run the Difference Audit, then the Fair Challenge Test. A difference that clears both is put to the person through the eight-move challenge process, one discrepancy at a time, with evidence introduced through the Disclosure Ladder:

  1. Settle the person's exact position and invite correction.
  2. Signal the change of task: “There are some discrepancies we need to discuss.”
  3. Place one material discrepancy, beginning with a Bridge Question and deciding when further disclosure will help. Evidence enters through the Disclosure Ladder in a fixed order and only as far as the evidence plan allows: the Bridge Question first, then the Basis Statement, then Full Disclosure. Source-neutral questions come first, and the three are used in a fixed order, though not all three back to back on every discrepancy.
  4. Invite an explanation in open language.
  5. Protect the response: let the pause sit.
  6. Clarify new claims, sources, and changes.
  7. Preserve the original account, the evidence introduced, the response, and what remains unresolved.
  8. Reset: return to the account, take up another discrepancy, or stop.

If the person gives an explanation, explore it before disclosing more. Full Disclosure is the final introduction, not a finish line to race toward, and the Basis Statement is not an automatic stopping point. Before closing an interview that can properly continue, attempt Full Disclosure of the remaining material evidence. Return to any earlier answer that proved misleading.

Tools

ASCThe Difference Audit · the Fair Challenge Test · the Disclosure Ladder.

CreditedStrategic Use of Evidence (Pär Anders Granhag, Maria Hartwig and colleagues), which governs the evidence plan, including the Evidence Framing Matrix; the eight-move challenge process draws on Conversation Management (Shepherd & Griffiths) and PEACE · Shift-of-Strategy research (Luke & Granhag).

Across roles

Most often with suspects and respondents, but a witness's or victim's account can conflict with evidence too. The fairness is the same; the safeguards and sensitivity follow the role.

What it is not

An accusation. No bluffs, no evidence ploys, no overstating what a record shows, and no confession required for success.

Route

Where is this conversation going?

Cue

“Find the objective, then the next turn.”

Turn here when…

you've lost the thread; a new name, allegation, or piece of information changes the picture; too many topics are open at once; you're unsure what comes next; or the person's status changes. Also before the interview begins.

What you do

  • Re-check the objective: what does this interview need to establish?
  • Mark where you are and what is still open.
  • Choose the next branch from your plan, and tell the person about the transition.
  • Connect the interview to the case: what needs checking outside the room, and who should be interviewed next and in what order.
  • If the person's legal status changes, stop, meet the new requirements, and explain the process again.

Tools

CommonThe Route Map, a planning format widely used by interviewers and investigators (objective, topics, turning points, if-then branches, stopping points). ASC teaches it; ASC did not create it.

CreditedThe ACCESS Model (Assess, including action planning and preparation; Collect; Collate; Evaluate; Survey; Summarize), attributed to Eric Shepherd and colleagues · PEACE's planning and preparation stage.

Across roles

Interview order, contamination prevention, and status changes, such as a witness who becomes a suspect, are Route decisions.

What it is not

A script or a prediction of guilt. Branches are triggered by what the person says, never by demeanor.

Navigation Decisions

Four decisions. Stay, shift, stack, stop.

After every turn, decide:

Stay

when the current direction is still working. Don't change methods just to look busy.

Shift

when a different direction now fits. Tell the person when the task changes.

Stack

when a second direction supports the first. Name which one leads.

Stop

when authority, safety, fatigue, vulnerability, fairness, or information quality requires it. Stopping is a navigation decision, not a defeat. When you stop, close with the RETURN Sequence: Reorient, Echo, Take corrections, Unresolved, Road ahead, Note.

One direction leads

Several directions can be active at once, but one leads. Adapt might support Retrieve; Route might support Test. Naming the lead keeps the interview clear, and lets a supervisor or reviewer ask whether the direction fit the problem.

A common starting path, not a fixed one

Many interviews start the same way: plan the route, teach the standard, listen to the first account, then retrieve and clarify before anything is tested. That is a common starting path, not a sequence to follow. The moment the conversation needs something else, turn to it, and come back when you're ready. Adapt and Re-engage are available at any moment, and any direction can be revisited.

What's Joe's

Joe Auriemma developed

The Compass and its eight directions, the “Which way?” check, the four navigation decisions and the rule that one direction leads, Teach to Talk and TEACH, the Pen Standard and Pen Contrast, Communication Adaptation, Barrier Mapping, the Difference Audit, and the Fair Challenge Test. Three more build on established work: the four sources of an account (a plain-language version of source-monitoring research), the Disclosure Ladder (three ways of introducing evidence in a fixed order; the Bridge Question has the form of the Reid bait question, and the Basis Statement and Full Disclosure draw on Strategic Use of Evidence and the challenge stage of PEACE), and the RETURN Sequence (a way of carrying out the Closure stage of PEACE). Protecting the first account is established practice drawn from PEACE, the Cognitive Interview, and Strategic Use of Evidence; ASC teaches it and does not claim it. All are practitioner-developed and research-informed; as an integrated method they have not yet been independently validated.

What's credited

ASC integrates, with credit

The Cognitive Interview (Fisher & Geiselman), Strategic Use of Evidence (Granhag, Hartwig & colleagues), the PEACE framework (England and Wales), the ACCESS Model (Shepherd & colleagues), TEDS-PIE and PLATO, and the research named in each direction. The Route Map is a planning format widely used by interviewers and investigators; ASC teaches it but does not claim it. Placing a method inside the Compass does not make it ASC's, and its research support belongs to its originators.

What the Compass is

A decision guide, not a truth detector.

Because the Compass has not been validated as a whole, Joe is precise about what it is. It is a decision guide: a structured way of choosing the next task when an interview struggles. It is not a psychological test, it does not detect deception, and it does not tell the interviewer whether an account is true. Until it is independently evaluated, the standard it is held to is whether it makes decisions consistent, explainable, and reviewable.

A fair objection is that any framework can be used after the fact to justify what an interviewer already wanted to do, such as turning to Test or Re-engage whenever they feel like applying pressure. The Compass is built to make that harder, not easier. Every turn has to name an observable condition, the other explanations considered, the safeguard, and the feedback expected. Those decisions are recorded at the time where possible, and any later reconstruction is labeled as such. The “Which way?” questions are asked in a fixed priority order, so the questions about the task, the interviewer’s own contribution, memory, meaning, and communication come before any conclusion that the person is unwilling or that the account conflicts with the evidence. Test requires a settled account, the Difference Audit, and the Fair Challenge Test before anything is raised. And no direction is an escalation: changing direction changes the task, never the pressure.

That makes the Compass an audit trail. A supervisor, a reviewer, or a court can read why each change of direction happened and judge whether the reason held up. Where a part of the method rests on research, such as the Cognitive Interview, Strategic Use of Evidence, or the protection of the first account, that research is credited to its authors and keeps its own limits. Where a part is ASC’s, it is labeled practitioner-developed and proposed for testing. How the Compass itself can be evaluated, including results that would show it does not work.

Like a real compass, it doesn’t give you a script. It gives you direction.

Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr., Founder, Advanced Strategic Communications
See the Compass in Your World

Pick your context. See the eight directions in your setting.

The directions don’t change from room to room; what they look like does. Every view starts from the same “Which way?” check. Role and setting change the safeguards, not the standard.

The Compass at a glance

The core question each direction answers. Pick a context above to see it in that setting.

Teach

Do they know how to do this? Teach the standard again and check by performance.

Listen

Is this still their account? Give the floor back and protect the answer.

Retrieve

Is there more they genuinely remember? Offer another route into memory, never a guess.

Clarify

Do I understand what they mean, and how they know it? Settle meaning, source, and certainty.

Adapt

Is how I'm communicating working? Observe, consider, adjust, verify.

Re-engage

Can they answer, but won't? Find the barrier and address it fairly.

Test

Does the account hold up against the evidence? Settle it, then put one discrepancy at a time.

Route

Where is this conversation going? Re-check the objective and choose the next turn.

One framework for victims, witnesses, and suspects. Navigate the condition, not the role.

Run the “Which way?” check →

Print the Compass poster →

Browse the full training catalog →
Why This Exists

The Compass is the navigation tool inside Teach to Talk. Teach to Talk grew out of the lessons of a homicide investigation Joe carries with him every day. The Compass came years later, as he refined his course and studied the research.

Read the Nunez Case ›

Bring the Compass to your room.

Every ASC course is built on the Adaptive Strategies Compass. Browse the training catalog to find the course calibrated for your operational context, or schedule a conversation about a custom engagement. See also Methodologies.