Home/About/The Nunez Case
A closed interrogation room door in a quiet law enforcement hallway
The Case That Built the Method

The Nunez Interrogation: The Case That Changed How I Train

An origin story for Teach to Talk®, written by Joseph R. Auriemma, Jr.

On November 29, 2011, Thomas Kolman Jr. was found dead in the parking lot of a Planet Fitness in the Town of Ulster, New York. The medical examiner ruled the death an acute midazolam poisoning. The lead suspect was Tom's best friend, Dr. Gilberto Nunez, a Kingston dentist.

On February 7, 2012, I was one of two investigators who sat across from Dr. Nunez for the second interview of this investigation. That interview ran roughly six hours. A substantial portion of it never reached the jury.

This is the case that became the foundation of Teach to Talk. It is also the case that has stayed with me every day since. The Adaptive Strategies Compass came years later, as I refined my course and studied the research.

He was describing my work.
What the Court Said

What the Court Said

When Judge Donald Williams sentenced Dr. Nunez in February 2017, he described, on the record, what he had watched on the recording of that February 7th interview. He called it “roughly six hours of some of the most aggressive, accusatorial interrogation” (as reported by CBS News). In that interview I accused the man across the table of murdering his best friend.

He was describing my work.

Before trial, Dr. Nunez's defense team moved to suppress the statements taken during that interview on Miranda and voluntariness grounds. They won. The court precluded a substantial portion of what we obtained, and the jury never saw the recording in full. At the time, we read his calm under hours of accusation as meaningful. I now teach the opposite: demeanor is not evidence of guilt or innocence, and an interview built on reading it puts the whole case at risk.

The jury deliberated for six hours (Hudson Valley One). They acquitted him of second-degree murder.

The Cost the Record Does Not Show

The Cost the Record Does Not Show

The court file ends with the verdict and with the sentencing on the unrelated forgery, insurance fraud, and pistol permit charges. The human file does not.

In the years that followed, the Kolman family carried losses no court document accounts for.

I do not write this to claim a result I did not cause, and I do not write it to absolve myself of one I might have. I write it because anyone who teaches investigative interviewing, particularly any law enforcement officer who steps into a room with a grieving family on one side and a presumptively innocent suspect on the other, owes the work the honesty of admitting what is at stake. The work is not abstract. The methodology is not academic. People are watching, and people are bearing the weight of every choice we make in that room, long after we go home.

I built these tools because I did not have them when I needed them.
Why I Built Teach to Talk

Why I Built Teach to Talk

I was trained the way most American investigators of my generation were trained. The accusatorial framework I used on February 7, 2012, was not an outlier. It was the standard. It was what the profession taught, what the manuals endorsed, and what the courts had not yet meaningfully pushed back against.

What I learned from this case, and what the judge said out loud at sentencing, is that an accusatorial interview carries real legal risk, and in this case that risk came due: the case went to trial without a substantial portion of the interview.

In the years since, the field has moved. Research funded by the FBI’s High-Value Detainee Interrogation Group (HIG) has found, in experimental studies, that information-gathering methods reduced false confessions without reducing true ones, compared with accusatorial methods. In 2021, an international group of experts led by former UN Special Rapporteur Juan E. Méndez published the Méndez Principles on Effective Interviewing. A growing number of states, beginning with Illinois and Oregon in 2021, have begun restricting deceptive interrogation of juveniles. The Reid Technique is commonly categorized by critics and researchers as an accusatorial interrogation model, and the empirical research on accusatorial methods has found that they can increase the risk of false confessions, particularly when combined with coercive pressure, minimization, maximization, deception, or questioning of vulnerable suspects. Reid & Associates disputes the claim that the properly applied Reid Technique causes false confessions. What I can speak to is my own investigative practice. In February 2012, I was one of two investigators who interviewed Dr. Nunez, and I used the accusatorial approach I had been trained in. A substantial portion of that interview was suppressed, and the jury acquitted him of murder. What looked like the standard in 2012 is no longer the standard. ASC is the training built for what comes next.

Teach to Talk is the method I built in response. It is not a refined version of accusatorial work. It is the alternative to it. Teach to Talk is a complete investigative interviewing method built on one idea: before you ask a person for an important account, teach them how the conversation works, and teach the interviewer how to protect what they say. One standard for victims, witnesses, and suspects. It is rapport-based and practitioner-developed. It never bluffs, lies, or uses coercive pressure or manipulation, and when it tests an account, it challenges the account, not the person. It is research-informed: its rapport-based, non-coercive approach is consistent with research funded by the FBI HIG and with the Méndez Principles (2021), and it draws on research-supported methods (Granhag, Hartwig, Fisher, Geiselman). The method as a whole has not been independently tested. Its signature line is Teach first. Then ask. Its working rule fits in one sentence: you don't need a script, you need a strategy.

The Adaptive Strategies Compass is the navigation tool inside Teach to Talk. When an interview starts to struggle, it tells you which way to turn. It has eight directions, no fixed order, one for each reason an interview struggles, and I now teach every one of them, with their tools, in every ASC course:

Together, these directions and tools replace the pressure I once used with a method built to produce information that is more reliable, more humane, and built to withstand legal review.

The interview is the case.
What This Case Teaches

What This Case Teaches

Three principles from this case shape every course I teach.

The interview is the case.

When testimonial evidence is the spine of a prosecution, the suppression hearing is the trial. Anything in the room a court can later call coercive, custodial without warning, or involuntary is anything that can collapse the case before opening statements. The interview is not preparation for the case. It is the case.

You don't need pressure. You need a strategy.

People do not tell the truth because they are forced to. They tell the truth because they feel safe enough, heard enough, and respected enough to. Rapport matters, but the premise of Teach to Talk is simpler: before I ask a person for an important account, I teach them how the conversation will work, show them with a pen, confirm they can do it, and then hold both of us to that standard.

The cost of getting it wrong is not measured in case files. It is measured in families.

A wrongful conviction is a catastrophe. So is a case that comes apart because of how the interview was conducted, whatever the truth turns out to be. The standard for our work is not whether we produced an admission. It is whether we produced information that was accurate, admissible, and proportionate to the gravity of what we were investigating.

Train With Me

Train With Me

I discuss the Nunez case during my investigative interviewing courses. Not as a war story, and not as a confession. As the foundation of a methodology built by someone who has stood inside the consequence and decided to spend the rest of his career making sure other investigators do not have to.

If your agency, department, academy, or program is ready to take a serious look at how your investigators interview, contact ASC for course offerings, on-site training, and the full Teach to Talk curriculum.